Georgia Prenups Follow a Three-Part Test
Before 1982, Georgia treated prenuptial agreements settling alimony as void against public policy. That changed with Scherer v. Scherer, in which the Georgia Supreme Court established a three-part test that still governs enforceability today. A court asks whether the agreement was obtained through fraud, duress, mistake, or nondisclosure of material facts, whether the agreement is unconscionable, and whether circumstances have changed enough since signing to make enforcement unfair.
This decision reversed decades of Georgia precedent treating any agreement anticipating a future divorce as fundamentally against public policy, opening the door to enforceable premarital contracts for the first time in the state's history.
A Roswell family lawyer drafts every prenuptial agreement with this three-part test carefully in mind, since a document that fails even one prong can be set aside entirely, regardless of how carefully the rest of the agreement was written.
What Counts as Full Financial Disclosure
The first prong of the Scherer test turns heavily on whether each spouse had a genuine understanding of the other's financial picture before signing. Courts expect a detailed schedule of assets, debts, and income attached to or referenced within the agreement itself, rather than a general statement that disclosure occurred.
Georgia courts have set aside agreements where one spouse concealed a business interest, hid significant debt, or otherwise left the other spouse without a realistic picture of what they were agreeing to at the time of signing. A spouse who later discovers a hidden asset can use that discovery to challenge the entire agreement's enforceability.
When a Court Finds an Agreement Unconscionable
The second prong asks whether the agreement's terms were so one-sided that they shock the conscience, either at the time of signing or at the time enforcement is sought. An extreme alimony waiver that would leave one spouse destitute, or an asset division wildly disproportionate to what each spouse brought into the marriage, tends to draw this kind of scrutiny.
Georgia courts retain the authority to modify or refuse to enforce a provision that would leave a spouse eligible for public assistance, even when the rest of the agreement otherwise satisfies the Scherer test.
Changes That Can Undermine an Otherwise Valid Agreement
The third prong looks at whether circumstances have shifted so significantly since the agreement was signed that enforcing it now would be unfair. A dramatic, unanticipated change in either spouse's health, finances, or family circumstances can sometimes support this argument, even when the original agreement was fair and voluntary at the time.
This prong is applied narrowly, and ordinary life changes that both spouses could reasonably have anticipated at the time of signing generally do not meet this standard.
What Couples Should Prepare Before Signing
Building an agreement that can survive scrutiny under all three Scherer prongs starts well before the wedding. Useful preparation includes:
- A complete, itemized disclosure of each spouse's assets, debts, and income
- Independent legal counsel for each spouse rather than one shared attorney
- Adequate time before the wedding to review and negotiate the terms
- Provisions that remain reasonable even if circumstances change over time
- A signed record confirming both spouses understood what they were agreeing to
How Vayman & Teitelbaum, P.C. Builds Agreements That Hold Up
Every prenuptial agreement eventually faces the same three-part test if it is ever challenged. Vayman & Teitelbaum, P.C. drafts agreements with the Scherer standard in mind from the very first conversation, aiming for terms that hold up whether or not they are ever actually contested in court.
Your Next Step
A prenuptial agreement built around Georgia's specific enforceability standard offers real protection precisely because it can withstand a later challenge in court. If you are planning a wedding in the Roswell area, a Roswell family lawyer can help you build an agreement that satisfies all three prongs of the Scherer test from the outset.